Option Pricing in Financial Derivatives: Why Risk‑Neutral Probabilities Determine Option Value in a One‑Step Binomial Model

Answer First: What does risk‑neutral pricing say?

In a one‑step binomial model, the fair price of a European call option today is the discounted expected payoff under the risk‑neutral probability measure:

\[ C_0 = \frac{q \cdot C_u + (1 – q) \cdot C_d}{1 + r} \]

The risk‑neutral probability is:

\[ q = \frac{(1 + r) – d}{u – d} \]

This probability is not a forecast. It is the unique probability that forces the stock’s expected return to equal the risk‑free rate, ensuring no‑arbitrage.

Problem Setup

Graduate‑level example:

A stock currently trades at \(S_0 = 100\). Over the next period, it can move up by 20% or down by 10%. The risk‑free rate for the period is \(r = 5\%\). Consider a European call option with strike \(K = 100\).

  • Up factor: \(u = 1.20\)
  • Down factor: \(d = 0.90\)
  • Risk‑free rate: \(r = 0.05\)
  • Current stock price: \(S_0 = 100\)
  • Strike price: \(K = 100\)

Tasks:

  1. Compute the risk‑neutral probability \(q\).
  2. Compute the call payoffs in each state.
  3. Compute the fair call price using risk‑neutral valuation.
  4. Verify the price using a replicating portfolio.

Step‑by‑Step Solution

Step 1: Compute the risk‑neutral probability

\[ q = \frac{(1 + r) – d}{u – d} \]

\[ q = \frac{1.05 – 0.90}{1.20 – 0.90} = \frac{0.15}{0.30} = 0.5 \]

The risk‑neutral probability of the up move is \(q = 0.5\).

Step 2: Compute stock prices and call payoffs

\[ S_u = 100 \cdot 1.20 = 120 \]

\[ S_d = 100 \cdot 0.90 = 90 \]

Call payoff in the up state:

\[ C_u = \max(120 – 100, 0) = 20 \]

Call payoff in the down state:

\[ C_d = \max(90 – 100, 0) = 0 \]

Step 3: Price the call using risk‑neutral valuation

\[ C_0 = \frac{0.5 \cdot 20 + 0.5 \cdot 0}{1.05} = \frac{10}{1.05} \approx 9.52 \]

The fair price of the call is approximately \(9.52\).

Step 4: Verify using a replicating portfolio

We solve for \(\Delta\) shares of stock and \(B\) dollars in the risk‑free asset:

\[ \Delta S_u + B(1 + r) = C_u \]

\[ \Delta S_d + B(1 + r) = C_d \]

Subtract the equations:

\[ 30\Delta = 20 \Rightarrow \Delta = \frac{2}{3} \]

Plug into the down‑state equation:

\[ \frac{2}{3} \cdot 90 + 1.05B = 0 \]

\[ 60 + 1.05B = 0 \Rightarrow B = -\frac{60}{1.05} \approx -57.14 \]

Cost of the replicating portfolio:

\[ \Pi_0 = \frac{2}{3} \cdot 100 – 57.14 = 66.67 – 57.14 \approx 9.52 \]

Replication confirms the risk‑neutral price.

Intuition

Risk‑neutral pricing works because we construct a synthetic world where every asset grows at the risk‑free rate. In that world, the only thing that matters is the discounted expected payoff. This removes investor preferences, risk aversion, and subjective probabilities from the pricing process.

This logic underpins binomial trees, Black–Scholes, and most derivatives models used in practice.

Common Exam Mistakes

  • Using subjective probabilities instead of risk‑neutral \(q\).
  • Forgetting to discount the expected payoff.
  • Mixing up \(u\) and \(d\).
  • Incorrect call payoffs.
  • Not verifying with replication when required.

Why This Matters in Real MBA/MSF Work

This model underpins:

  • Equity option valuation
  • Employee stock option analysis
  • Risk‑neutral pricing on trading desks
  • Structured product design

For more applied examples, see the Finance Blog, where these concepts appear in valuation, hedging, and risk‑management contexts.

Final Summary

The one‑step binomial model shows that option prices come from discounted expected payoffs under risk‑neutral probabilities. These probabilities enforce no‑arbitrage and lead to the same price as a replicating portfolio. This is the foundation for all advanced derivatives models.


This explanation belongs to the broader Finance Tutoring NYC pillar.

If you want help working through these ideas for coursework or exams, you can talk directly to a tutor, not a marketer.

Call/Text: 646-543-0832
Email: tutor@mytutornyc.com